Revisiting the Introductory Challenge

Re-read

Re-read the conversation between Tanisha and Shelley in light of what you’ve learned from his unit:

Tanisha:
I’m just so mad at the kids who pick on James in that math class! Miss McGregor is clueless. I can’t talk to her.

Shelley:
Yeah, she’s a new teacher. She has a lot to learn.

Tanisha:
No kidding! She needs to learn it fast.

Shelley:
It won’t be fast enough for James, I’m sorry to say. Sometimes I wonder where they find these teachers!

Tanisha:
Do you think I should move James to a different school? Would that make things better?

Shelley:
Maybe. Well, I don’t think anybody’s gonna do much for James here. He’s a sweet kid, but lots of kids here are just mean. Their parents don’t care, like you do!  I’m real sorry for James. Maybe it would be a good idea to get him out of here.

Tanisha:
Thanks Shelley, you’re a good friend. I’m gonna think some more about this. I wish you could come with us to the new school!

Questions

  1. How could Shelley have been more discrete?
  2. What’s missing that would have helped Shelley be more dependable?
  3. Is Shelley being impartial here? Why or why not? (This is not like breaking up a fight…or is it?)
  4. She’s clearly not being loyal to her instructional team, but is she being loyal to the work? What do you think?
  5. What more would you need to know to judge Shelley’s loyalty to the work?